Equipment Lease vs. Buy: Compare Cost and Ownership
Original publisher: Mehmi Financial Group · Published · Source updated
Canada
Updated November 20, 2026: The cost comparison, tax references and contract questions were revised.
Quick answer: A lease and a purchase can differ in ownership, upfront cash, payments, buyout and return obligations. Compare complete written offers over the same period and with the same end-of-term outcome. Tax and accounting treatment depend on the agreement, applicable rules and the business's circumstances.
For a Canadian business choosing a truck, machine or other asset, a lower monthly payment alone does not establish which option costs less. A lease may include a final purchase option or require the equipment to be returned; a loan may leave the borrower owning the asset subject to the lender's security. Read the actual documents.
Compare the same outcome
Ask each provider for equipment price, upfront payments, payment frequency and start date, all fees, end-of-term buyout or return charges, and early termination terms. Add insurance, sales tax, delivery, installation, repairs and downtime if they are excluded. If you intend to own the asset, include the purchase option and any fee in the lease comparison. If you plan to return it, consider usage limits and return condition.
Confirm who owns the equipment during the term and after the final payment, which business or personal assets are pledged and whether a personal guarantee is required. Neither the word lease nor loan alone establishes the security package or the right to return equipment early.
Worked example: owning the same asset after five years
This is a hypothetical Canadian-dollar comparison, not a customer case or lender quote. Assume CAD $80,000 of equipment, a five-year use period and ownership at the end. Taxes, insurance, delivery, maintenance and the time value of money are excluded. These inputs are not market rates.
- Loan illustration: CAD $80,000 financed at a fixed nominal 10% annually, calculated monthly, with 60 equal end-of-month payments and no down payment, fees or balloon. The estimated payment is CAD $1,699.76 per month and the unrounded schedule totals about CAD $101,985.81.
- Lease illustration: CAD $1,000 upfront, 60 end-of-month payments of CAD $1,500 and a CAD $12,000 purchase option paid at the end. Assuming the option is exercised, total cash paid is CAD $103,000.
In these particular illustrations the lease payment is lower, but ownership through the lease costs about CAD $1,014.19 more over the term. The difference uses the unrounded loan schedule. This is not an APR or a tax-adjusted comparison; different fees, rates, payment timing, residual values or maintenance obligations can change the result. A lower payment may not fit if the final option cannot be funded.
Use the quote comparison tool to enter written proposals, including buyouts and fees. Its output is a planning estimate, not a contract, offer or tax calculation.
Tax and accounting require a contract-specific review
The Canada Revenue Agency's guidance discusses leasing costs and certain leasing elections and capital cost allowance for eligible depreciable property. Eligibility, business use, the agreement and special rules can affect deductions. Do not assume every lease payment is fully deductible or every financed purchase produces the same deduction.
Financial-statement treatment also depends on the agreement and the accounting standards applicable to the business. Ask a qualified accountant to review the contract; do not assume a lease is automatically off balance sheet.
Questions before deciding
- How much cash is due at signing and before the equipment operates?
- What is the total payment schedule, including any final purchase option?
- Who maintains and insures the equipment, and what happens after a total loss?
- What fees or obligations apply if the business exits early?
- Which assets and guarantees secure the obligation?
- How does the payment fit a slower month and the equipment's expected useful life?
Frequently asked questions
Is a lease always cheaper each month?
No. The rate, term, fees and end-of-term amount affect payments. Compare actual written terms for the same asset and outcome.
Do I own financed equipment immediately?
Ownership and the lender's security depend on the agreement. Ask who holds title and what happens after final payment.
Can a business buy leased equipment?
Some leases include a purchase option; others have different return or renewal terms. Review the contract and the option amount.
General education only; not legal, tax or accounting advice. Financing, availability and terms depend on the provider, location and transaction.
Compare your equipment financing options
Check upfront cash, scheduled payments, fees and end-of-term costs using the details in your written offers.
Compare written quotes